Copyright “This David Pawson video is the copyright of ©David Pawson Teaching Trust 2020 and is streamed with the permission of the David Pawson Teaching Trust. For a full library of David’s teaching resources please visit www.davidpawson.org”
Thoughtful Thoughts 23.5.25 by John Dunning.
The Christian Story Pt. 11; Reasons for the “Reformation”; Pt. 2
1). PROLOGUE…
What we believe affects our behaviour. That is why it is important to examine the Scriptures to see what God says, just as the Bereans did.
One of the most famous paintings of all time is Michelangelo’s “The Last Judgement”, but do you know what inspired it? Well, are you sitting comfortably? Then I’ll begin!
Because there is a genuine Biblical truth about God, there has been a counterfeit man-made religion which resulted in men blaming God for what was nothing more than yet another man-made religion, established only by the use of physical force, which we will be looking at further, in this study.
Last time we looked at the Catholic “Mass”… This time we will study another theological issue showing why the church desperately needed reforming, which was its theology of “Apostolic Succession”, and what it led to…
This study can be seen to be relevant and important when we realise that people need to heed the inspiration of the Holy Spirit and be led both in the present, and in our understanding of the Scriptures.
–
2). INTRODUCTION…
There was a ‘believer’ called Simon (Acts 8:18-24) who saw the amazing power God had given to Peter through the Holy Spirit, and Simon wanted that power. Simon offered money to Peter if he could have the Holy Spirit. Immediately Peter rejected Simon and noted that Simon’s wish to have power and control was Satanic. Bear this passage in mind during this study.
Jesus said that the Holy Spirit would be His replacement on earth, (Acts 1:8), after He returned to His Father in heaven. It is the Holy Spirit who tells us what our heavenly Father wants. That means “who” God wants to do “what”…
–
3). “APOSTOLIC SUCCESSION”.
The founder of one religion said to his son that to make money you start a religion. With that thought, how did bishops of Rome stay in power? We are about to find out…
When I queried the difference between Bible teaching and Catholic teaching with a Catholic priest at Gatwick, he explained that he followed the Vatican encyclicals, (which are sort of like circular letters). That justified him teaching and practising Catholic teaching. When I queried how that fitted against the authority of the Bible, he said that church tradition was his authority, and justified following Vatican encyclicals.
“Apostolic Succession” sounds Biblical, but it is just an excuse to keep control. It was like a relay race, where their own religious “baton” was passed on to like minded insiders.
That meant that those in power kept their position as they were the same people deciding who would be next in line…
Senior clergy appointed their own fan club to be next in line, and to make it all sound very religious, they coined the term “Apostolic Succession”, and to make “Apostolic Succession” sound Biblical they justified it by using “The laying on of hands”.
All this was the opposite of what Jesus had said, that the church would be governed by the Holy Spirit. He was the one who Jesus said would be “in the place of Christ on earth”, directing us.
–
4). “I’M IN CHARGE”…
Out of sheer anger, an army in 1527 that was NOT getting paid, over-ran one of the world’s most corrupt cities on earth, Rome, when it was still controlled by Pope Clement 7th. Pope Clement 7th only escaped by running to a fortress aided by Swiss soldiers, who were mostly killed during his escape. As the Popes were more like a mafia, they needed personal bodyguards, and so Swiss guards were appointed to provide that service.
Popes used the armies of Catholic kings as the enforcer of their “Apostolic Succession” and by not going along with them appointing themselves as head of state, you would endanger your health, as they used the force of arms to have their self generated title of “Father” & “In the place of Christ on earth”, recognised by all.
The Protestant Lutherans used the sack of Rome in 1547, as proof of church corruption, which justified Luther & other reformers becoming whistleblowers.
Michelangelo’s “The Last Judgement” painting had many hidden meanings criticising the church which they didn’t realise until it was too late.
How did the church manage to get into such a mess?
When the Vatican came up with a very corporate business idea of “Apostolic Succession”, to copy how Kings created their own line of succession, they enforced it using armies which led onto behaving however they wanted. It went from bad to worse until the scandals increased so much under the blood line of Borgia Popes from 1378 onwards, that there were severe conflicts.
There were even two Popes in Pope Clement 7th (1478-1534), day. (And in 1409 there were even three popes with more conflicts over who would be Pope. That was when the unpaid army took Rome by force.
–
Sack of Rome of 1527 by Johannes Lingelbach
VATICAN ARGUMENTS…
a). An early bishop of Rome claimed to be the senior bishop over all other bishops. An initial argument used was that as Rome had the biggest church he was the senior bishop.
One of the titles popes still give themselves is “Supreme Pontiff of the Universal Church”, meaning that Popes still consider themselves to be in charge of the whole church throughout the world. In this way Popes claimed to be the “first” among all other churchmen.
–
Answer to;
a). above;- Jesus commanded that no disciple could set themselves up over others.
Peter ended up humbling himself to the point where he wouldn’t even be crucified the same way up as Jesus. At the time, many bishops around Europe refused to accept the bishop of Rome being superior.
Then there were the original English bishops in 597AD, who also refused to accept the Pope trying to take-over the church. It was only decades later in 1066, when another Pope saw an opportunity to conquer England by helping William the Conqueror pillage England under his papal flag (called a “falon”), in William the Conqueror’s battle of Hastings in 1066.
–
b). The next Vatican argument was that Peter was the first bishop of Rome, so they became Peter’s successor. So, another title Popes gave themselves was (and still do) was; “Successor of the Prince of the Apostles” (Successor principis apostolorum).
To get to that, the Vatican argued that the Apostle Peter was appointed by Jesus as the rock on which the church was built, and then being the first bishop of Rome as the first Pope, meant that the next bishop of Rome became Peter’s successor as Pope. It was what is called a circular argument, which is not allowed for building a case in court. (That changed to where cardinals elected Popes worldwide.)
–
b). above;- The Vatican argument ignores the fact that Peter could never have been in Rome, because all Jews had been sent into exile from Rome by Emperor Claudius.
When Peter was still alive and an apostle, the Roman Emperor Claudius had banned Jews from being in Rome. As Peter was a Jew he could not have been in Rome as no-one disobeyed a Roman emperor, on penalty of death. (Which was crucifixion for non-citizens, and beheading for citizens. Later, Paul was in Rome because he was a Roman citizen and was being taken for trial before the Emperor, which was his constitutional right. Peter was not a Roman citizen and never had that right.)
–
5). TITLES;-
Popes take many titles for themselves. Just two are examined next…
a). Call me “Father”.
The title “Pope” which the bishop of Rome takes for himself means “Father”.
Answer…
Jesus commanded that we ONLY call God “Father”, (and not anyone else.) Matthew 23:9 “And do not call anyone on earth ‘father,’ for you have one Father, and he is in heaven.”
–
b). “In the place of Christ…”
Another official title which Popes give themselves is the title, “Vicar of Jesus Christ”. The word, “vicar” is a shortened Latin form for vicarious meaning, “in the place of…”, so in English “vicar of Christ” means “in the place of Christ”. So Popes claim they are in the place of Christ on earth. It was first used in 445AD when Pope Leo gave himself the title “the vicar of Peter” in a letter, (i.e. claiming to be the next rock on which the church was being built.) From there it grew like a snowball, and was also upgraded to “Vicar of Jesus Christ”. Then in 1073, Pope Gregory 7 commanded that no other bishop use that title.
Answer:
This is the opposite of Jesus’ teaching, as He teaches that the Holy Spirit would replace Him; (Acts 1:8).
When the bishop of Rome decided that he would be “in the place of Christ”, that meant that he would be running the church. The corruption that followed took Europe into the “Dark Ages”, after Rome fell.
(If you thought life was bad under the Romans, check out life in Europe under the Church of Rome between the fall of Rome in the 5th century and the decline of the Roman Catholic Church.)
Throughout the empire of the Catholic church, a priest received what was called “Benefit of Clergy”, meaning they got away with any wrongdoing. Priests were treated like the mythical Greek demi-gods. Only a church court could discipline clergy.
The Kipling Society defines this Benefit of Clergy in this way; “By strict definition, ‘Benefit of Clergy’ was the right of exemption from trial in a secular court by those in Holy Orders”. Hundreds of years after Britain turned its back on Rome, the “Criminal Law Act” of 1827 removed the Benefit of Clergy, where Catholic countries had allowed clergy to commit crimes without punishment, allowing the church to be the home for national corruption, as no-one else was exempt.
–
6). EPILOGUE
Last time we saw that the responsibility remains with us to take responsibility to be like Bereans by sticking to God’s Word. Reformers were focussing on Biblical teaching, putting Scripture first, like the Bereans. So, the spiritual tide started turning, but it was not without a fight, as it was spiritual warfare. The church used murder and torture to enforce its traditions on those who followed Scripture instead of church tradition.
But what the Bible says in Acts 2:38, is that to start our journey of salvation, we must;
a). Repent,
b). Be immersed,
c). And receive the Holy Spirit.
Read Acts 2:38, Pray about Acts 2:38, Act on Acts 2:38…
Notice that the Holy Spirit follows on after immersion, which follows on after repentance.
John’s final encouragement to the saints, reminded them of Jesus coming back for His faithful disciples when he finished Revelation, “Even so, come Lord Jesus”.
Michelangelo’s “The Last Judgement”.
This is John Dunning signing off from “Thoughtful Thoughts” for another week.